Self Help

5 Elements of Effective Thinking, The - Burger, Edward B. & Starbird, Michael

Author Photo

Matheus Puppe

· 17 min read

“If you liked the book, you can purchase it using the links in the description below. By buying through these links, you contribute to the blog without paying any extra, as we receive a small commission. This helps us bring more quality content to you!”



  • Brilliant students and innovators are not born that way, they develop habits of effective thinking that lead to success. Genius does not appear magically or in a single leap.

  • The authors have taught many students and adults strategies for improving their thinking. They have seen these methods lead to dramatic transformations in people’s abilities.

  • Effective thinking involves mastering a few basic strategies like learning from mistakes, asking questions, and building on previous ideas. These methods can be learned by anyone.

  • The book will present practical, proven techniques to improve thinking and foster creativity and innovation. By applying these strategies, anyone can achieve greater success.

  • The story of two hypothetical students, Anne and Adam, will illustrate how developing habits of effective thinking leads to growth and thriving.

In essence, the introduction establishes that genius and brilliance are not inborn traits, but rather are achieved through mastering simple methods of thinking that anyone can learn and apply. The book will equip readers with these powerful techniques.

  • Education does not end with formal schooling. You can always improve your thinking and learning habits. Apply the methods in this book to become more successful in school, work, and life.

  • Understanding deeply, making mistakes, asking questions, and following ideas are four key strategies for effective thinking and learning.

  • Understand simple ideas deeply before tackling complexity. Admit what you do and don’t know. Fill in gaps in understanding. Let go of biases.

  • Fail intentionally to succeed more. Mistakes highlight opportunities, reveal gaps in understanding, and ignite imagination.

  • Ask questions constantly to clarify and extend understanding. Find the real question. New ideas come from good questions.

  • Follow ideas to see where they originate and lead. Small ideas can lead to big payoffs.

  • Change is the quintessential element. By mastering the four strategies, you can change how you think and learn. Continually improve.

  • Read this book slowly three times - first for the big picture, second applying the ideas, third to internalize the methods.

  • The stories and exercises make the five elements practical for improving thinking in school, work, and life.

Here are a few key points about understanding deeply:

  • Seek to understand fundamental concepts and simple cases with ever-increasing depth. True mastery requires continually refining your understanding of basics.

  • Look for the core ideas behind complicated topics. Major breakthroughs often come from thinking deeply about everyday experiences, like observing a falling apple leading to calculus.

  • Identify gaps in your knowledge. Realizing what you don’t fully grasp allows you to focus on building true understanding from the ground up.

  • Simple is not the same as easy. Understanding the basics takes time and concentrated effort. But it provides a solid foundation to build upon.

  • Apply focused attention and reflection. Understanding emerges from actively engaging with material, not just passive exposure. Ask questions, make connections, test your knowledge.

  • There is always room for deeper understanding. Experts continue honing their mastery of fundamentals throughout their careers.

The key is being ruthlessly honest with yourself about the depth of your comprehension. Avoid superficial familiarity and seek true mastery. Mastering the basics unlocks the ability to excel at higher levels.

  • When faced with a difficult problem, break it down into simpler, more manageable sub-problems. Thoroughly solve the sub-problems first, as this will provide insights into the larger problem.

  • Isolate the essential core or principles of a complex issue. Ignore distracting or confusing elements initially to uncover the essence.

  • Returning often to mastering basics and fundamentals provides a strong foundation for learning more advanced material. As you advance, revisit basics from a more nuanced perspective.

  • Focus intently on small details and sub-problems. Don’t jump ahead to the bigger picture too quickly. Sweating the small stuff builds skills and insights that later allow you to handle complexity.

  • Problem solving requires patience and stepping back, not attacking complexity head-on. Take time to build fundamentals first. creative thinkers admit when something is too difficult initially and find an easier path in.

The key ideas are breaking problems down, isolating essence, mastering basics, focused attention on details, and indirect creative approaches rather than direct attacks on complexity.

  • Real issues are often obscured by surrounding history, context, and complications. By systematically stripping away the peripheral details, we can uncover the core themes and gain clearer understanding.

  • Pablo Picasso’s series of bull drawings illustrates this process of simplification to reveal essence. His final minimalist sketch entitled “The Bull” distills the animal’s strength and masculinity.

  • We all have biases and prejudices that color how we see the world. Acknowledging this and making an effort to set aside assumptions allows us to see things more objectively.

  • Shadows are actually the color of the sky, not just gray or black as commonly believed. Noticing details we overlook can lead to new perspectives.

  • In studying art, focus on plainly describing what you actually see, not what you think you are supposed to see. Admit what you don’t understand. Identifying gaps leads to learning.

  • Being honest about what we know and don’t know helps fill holes in understanding. The interface between knowledge and ignorance is where growth occurs.

  • People often accept ideas based on authority and repetition rather than evidence. This makes it hard to separate what we really know from what we just believe.

  • An example is Aristotle’s false idea that heavier objects fall faster, which people accepted uncritically for 2000 years.

  • The myth is that people instantly relied on evidence over authority after Galileo’s famous experiment disproving Aristotle. In reality, the shift was gradual.

  • To avoid unintended closed-mindedness, we can hypothetically try on alternative ideas, like Bohr did with quantum mechanics.

  • Another strategy is looking for what’s missing or invisible - identifying gaps in knowledge, using adjectives to highlight taken-for-granted aspects of reality, and uncovering new possibilities.

  • Regularly questioning the basis of our beliefs and opinions can lead to better understanding of ourselves and the world. We should ask “How do I know?” and seek evidence.

Here are a few key ideas on using mistakes productively:

  • Welcome mistakes - Don’t see them as failures, but as opportunities to learn. Mistakes show you where you need to improve.

  • Analyze mistakes - Dig into why something didn’t work. Identify the specific issues so you can address them.

  • Learn from mistakes - Use what you learn to adjust your approach and try again. Mistakes reveal gaps in your knowledge or flaws in your process.

  • Share mistakes - Discussing mistakes openly helps others learn as well. It builds understanding and prevents repeating the same errors.

  • Don’t repeat mistakes - Apply what you’ve learned to avoid making the same mistake multiple times. Continually refine your process.

  • Don’t fear mistakes - If you’re too afraid of mistakes, you won’t take risks and you’ll limit your learning. View them as a natural part of the learning process.

  • Laugh at mistakes - Keeping a sense of humor reduces stress and keeps things in perspective. Mistakes are part of being human.

The key is maintaining a positive mindset. Mistakes are not failures, but opportunities to gain insights and improve. By analyzing and learning from mistakes in a constructive way, you can fail your way to success!

  • Mary was a student who hated math but was forced to take a math class she had no interest in. She was disengaged in class.

  • One day the instructor posed a very challenging question about infinity and had students work in groups, knowing they would not be able to fully solve it. He called on Mary to share her group’s ideas.

  • Reluctantly, Mary shared her solution, which was wrong. But the instructor walked her through a process of identifying flaws, fixing them, and iterating to improve the solution.

  • After several iterations, Mary had an unexpectedly creative solution to the hard problem. This process made her feel liberated.

  • The instructor argues this shows the power of making attempts, finding flaws, and incrementally improving. Many famous creators and inventions followed this process of failing and iterating.

  • The key is not to expect perfection upfront but to make attempts, embrace errors, learn from mistakes, and improve step-by-step. This technique can be applied broadly.

Here are a few key ideas on how to turn failures into opportunities for growth and discovery:

  • View failures and mistakes as learning opportunities rather than disasters. Reflect on what went wrong and how you can improve for next time. Celebrate when students learn from mistakes.

  • Revisit and revise past work that was unsatisfactory. Use the feedback to strengthen weak areas and build on any gems in the work. Iteration and improvement require starting from an imperfect draft.

  • When an attempt fails, ask if it could be the solution to a different problem. Creative solutions sometimes come from unintentional directions.

  • Intentionally push ideas to extremes or break things to fully understand limits and vulnerabilities. Stress tests and hypotheticals reveal insights.

  • Encourage a growth mindset around failure. Praise efforts and processes more than outcomes. Model resilience and how to extract lessons from mistakes.

  • Allow students to learn from exam mistakes by redoing problems or replacing low scores. Incentivize fixing errors, not ignoring them.

  • Apply these principles not just in school but at all ages and in workplaces too. Failing is part of learning if you build on it in positive ways.

The key is shifting perspective to value the learning process over perfect outcomes. Failures become progress when treated as stepping stones rather than stumbling blocks.

Here are some key points on how creating questions can lead to insight and understanding:

  • Asking questions, even if you know the answer, can reveal assumptions, expose errors, and uncover alternatives. Framing good questions focuses attention on the right issues.

  • Generating questions yourself can guide you towards deeper understanding and creative problem solving. It forces deeper engagement with the world.

  • “What if…” questions invite you to challenge the status quo and explore the limits of your understanding. They help reveal what’s missing and needs creating.

  • When faced with a challenge or problem, ask “How can I improve?” and “What am I missing?” to uncover new perspectives.

  • Turn mistakes into questions like “What did I assume?” and “How can I do this differently?” to learn from errors.

  • Look for paradoxes and contradictions that create confusion and frame them as questions to gain clarity.

  • Asking questions engages your mind in active thinking rather than passive reception. It stimulates your creativity and curiosity.

  • Question yourself constantly with an inquisitive spirit, like Socrates did with his students. Be your own personal Socrates.

The key insight is that framing good questions, even if you know the answers, focuses your mind in a productive direction leading to new discoveries and solutions. Questioning yourself constantly with curiosity is a powerful thinking tool.

  • Asking basic questions openly, even if they seem “stupid”, demonstrates confidence and leads to greater understanding. Leaders should not be afraid to ask fundamental questions.

  • Acknowledging and overcoming biases by challenging preconceived notions and asking difficult questions from different perspectives leads to new insights.

  • Preparing for exams or presentations by creating your own test questions forces you to uncover gaps in understanding. Teaching a topic to others is an effective way to learn.

  • Asking questions in all aspects of life enlivens curiosity. Teachers and managers should encourage questions from students and employees.

  • Simple but insightful questions can get to the heart of complex issues, like Feynman’s O-ring demo that uncovered the cause of the Challenger disaster.

  • Practice tests and assignments under timed conditions similar to high-stakes assessments to prepare for performing under pressure.

  • Continually generating and asking probing questions leads to richer understanding and appreciation.

Here’s a summary of the key points:

  • Instead of asking if there are any questions, assume there are questions and have listeners take 60 seconds to write down 2 questions. Calling on people to share their questions encourages active listening and curiosity.

  • Constantly come up with your own questions, even if you don’t ask them out loud. This forces you to listen more attentively. Write your own test questions to check understanding.

  • Being an “official questioner” made one student listen more actively in class. Taking responsibility to ask questions yourself improves learning.

  • Many people ask the wrong questions in life, like pursuing money over happiness. Before answering, ask “What’s the real question here?”

  • Effective questions avoid vagueness, expose assumptions, clarify issues, and lead to action. They point your mind in productive directions.

  • Improve ineffective questions like “How can I get better grades?” to “How can I understand more deeply?” Better questions lead to more useful insights.

Here are a few key ideas on understanding current ideas through the flow of ideas:

  • Trace concepts back to their origins and simpler forms. Understanding where an idea came from and how it evolved over time provides crucial context.

  • Realize today’s ideas build on previous work. Newton stood “on the shoulders of giants.” Current ideas extend the work of past thinkers.

  • Ideas evolve gradually through many small steps. Major innovations are often the result of countless minor advances over time.

  • Apply familiar ideas in new contexts. Taking existing concepts and adapting them can lead to new breakthroughs.

  • See each idea as a moment in a continuing evolution. No idea is static - it can be extended, varied, and refined going forward.

  • Appreciate that genius emerges from struggle. Even brilliant minds take small, imperfect steps on the road to major insights.

The key is recognizing that today’s ideas have roots in the past, and future ideas will build on the present. Tracing this flow of concepts over time aids understanding.

Calculus is an idea that has been extraordinarily fruitful and influential across many fields, yet it originated from just a few key concepts laid out in a 6-page essay by Leibniz in 1684. Today’s calculus textbooks contain over 1,300 pages elaborating on variations and applications of those founding ideas. Effective learning involves seeing the interconnected flow of ideas rather than just memorizing disjointed facts. Looking back on previous concepts helps clarify new material and reveals how each idea builds on what came before. Making guesses about what will come next also connects ideas into an integrated whole. Every new discovery is just a small variation on existing knowledge. Pushing any concept further can uncover unforeseen applications and unintended consequences. Just as Edison built on previous innovations to create the lightbulb, the implications of any new idea are limitless if we continue to think creatively about extensions and variations. The most successful students and innovators take small steps to uncover consequences beyond an idea’s original purpose.

Here is a summary of the key points about mental icebergs and improving on ideas:

  • Ideas and innovations build on each other in an ongoing process of refinement and improvement. Just as the telephone evolved from a stationary device to smartphones, ideas in all fields evolve by taking the best of the past and improving on it.

  • We should not see current solutions as the summit or end point. The best can always get better. Newcomers and fresh perspectives are key to seeing current solutions as a starting point for further innovation.

  • Moving an idea forward often requires making it practical by following the hypothetical consequences and connections. This allows us to transition from thinking as a student to thinking as a practitioner.

  • To envision future ideas, look back at history and consider what we now view as ridiculous that was once accepted. This helps reveal our current blindspots. The flow of improving ideas leads to identifying problems in the present that may one day seem absurd.

  • The key is to constantly ask “What’s next?” and build on the best ideas, seeing each advance as the lower slope of a much higher peak yet to be scaled. This mindset of ongoing refinement is crucial for innovation and progress.

Here are a few key points on engaging change and transforming yourself:

  • Change can be difficult, but adopting the habit of continual improvement is liberating. Don’t be afraid to change any part of yourself - you’ll still be you, only better.

  • People who perform better can be viewed as doing a different task, not just the same task better. Great tennis players watch and track the ball differently than beginners. They engage in a different task.

  • To improve, focus on altering your process and approach, not just trying harder. Ask how you can tackle problems differently.

  • Change your environment and habits to make desired behaviors easier. Want to exercise more? Keep your workout clothes nearby.

  • Pursue “micro-wins” - small, concrete improvements you can make regularly. Tiny gains compound over time.

  • Don’t let setbacks discourage you. Progress isn’t linear. Persist through failures on the road to success.

  • Surround yourself with people who constructively challenge you to grow. Iron sharpens iron.

  • Keep exploring. Continuously look for new perspectives. The day we stop learning is the day we stop living.

The key is to make change a habit. Alter your mindset and behaviors bit by bit through consistent micro-wins. Progress compounds. You’ll look back one day and be amazed at how far you’ve come.

  • Doing a task with true understanding is easier than doing it by rote memorization or formulas without comprehension. Understanding provides context and meaning that makes facts and procedures more memorable.

  • To improve at something, focus on altering what you do - your approach, strategies, and perspective - rather than just trying harder at the same approach. Think “do it differently” rather than “do it better.”

  • Differences in innate ability are small compared to the power of methods and habits of thinking. With the right strategies and effort, we are all capable of far more creativity and achievement than we typically demonstrate.

  • Becoming an expert is not about reaching some magic hour of practice. It’s an incremental journey of deepening understanding, making mistakes, asking questions, and evolving ideas.

  • Einstein exemplified being willing to change course when evidence disproved his theories. A willingness to question assumptions and change is vital.

  • Letting go of old ideas in the face of doubt or challenges allows us to rebuild even better structures of understanding. Doubt can be a helpful tool, not a weakness.

The key is focusing on transforming our thinking process rather than just exerting more effort, and being willing to question assumptions and change course as needed. With the right mental habits and effort, we are all capable of expertise and creativity beyond what we imagine.

  • Strive for rock-solid understanding of fundamentals (Earth)
  • Learn from mistakes and failures (Fire)
  • Constantly ask challenging questions (Air)
  • Consider how ideas connect and build on each other (Water)
  • Learning is a lifelong journey, so keep evolving and improving (Quintessence)

The passage emphasizes deeply understanding basics, clearing away clutter to find essentials, seeing what’s missing, and mastering fundamentals. It advocates failing and learning from mistakes, asking challenging questions, and tracing the flow of ideas. The quintessence is lifelong learning and evolution. Key tips include mastering basics of a skill, outlining fundamentals of a subject, solving sub-problems thoroughly, isolating core ideas, boldly identifying gaps in knowledge, and lifelong habits for effective thinking. The goal is to keep improving, evolving, and becoming your quintessential self.

Here are the key points from the passages:

  • Admitting your own uncertainties is an important step toward solid understanding. Try on alternative viewpoints without judgment to better understand others’ perspectives.

  • Failures and mistakes can guide you to insights. Welcome them as learning opportunities. Exaggerate ideas to extremes to reveal flaws.

  • Teaching a subject forces you to confront fundamental questions about it, enhancing your own understanding. Craft focused questions to get to productive solutions.

  • Consider how current ideas evolved from past ones to gain new insights. Extend existing good ideas. Question your own assumptions.

  • Imagine how an expert would approach a task differently than you currently do. Their knowledge and skills would make it easier. Transform yourself through the learning process.

  • Apply the four elements of effective thinking (Earth, Fire, Air, Water) in your own life to improve your thinking skills. Adopt these as lifelong habits.

  • Develop rock-solid understanding (Earth) by deeply comprehending concepts.

  • Learn from failures and mistakes (Fire). See them as opportunities to improve.

  • Ask challenging questions (Air) to expand your thinking.

  • Consider different viewpoints and how ideas connect (Water).

  • Share stories of how you have used these elements in your personal or professional life. Big or small, these examples can inspire others.

  • If you know of other good examples of the elements in action, share the story and source.

  • Visit the book’s website to share your stories of effective thinking.

  • Learning is a lifelong journey. We are all works in progress, continuously evolving. That’s quintessential living.

The authors thank the many people who directly or indirectly helped conceptualize this book, including students, colleagues, family and friends. Special thanks to those who provided feedback on early versions. The authors are grateful to the Princeton University Press team for producing and promoting the book.

Author Photo

About Matheus Puppe