Self Help

The Personal MBA - Josh Kaufman

Author Photo

Matheus Puppe

· 39 min read

Here is a summary of the praise for The Personal MBA 10th Anniversary Edition:

The book receives praise from many notable business leaders and authors for distilling MBA-level business knowledge into an accessible guide. They highlight how the book provides applicable mental models, insights, and frameworks for understanding all aspects of business, from marketing to finance. The reviewers say the book is a valuable resource for entrepreneurs and business professionals, helping them make better decisions without formal business school training. Key strengths include the book’s brevity, practicality, empowering message, and ability to shortcut years of business education. Overall, the reviewers enthusiastically recommend the book as an essential volume for anyone interested in business.

Here is a summary of the key concepts covered in The Personal MBA:

Cash Flow Cycle - The continuous flow of money in and out of a business. Managing cash flow is critical for business survival.

Segregation of Duties - Separating critical financial tasks between multiple people to prevent fraud and error. An important internal control.

Limited Authorization - Restricting authority for certain transactions to specific trusted individuals. Another essential internal control.

Opportunity Cost - The value of the best alternative given up when deciding. Considering opportunity cost is crucial in decision making.

Time Value of Money: Money available at present is worth more than the identical sum in the future due to its potential earning capacity—the core principle of finance.

Compounding - Earning returns on previous returns greatly amplifies the final result. Leveraging compounding is powerful.

Leverage - Using a resource to access a much larger resource, like borrowing money to buy real estate. Can multiply gains and losses.

Hierarchy of Funding - The ordered sequence of funding sources, from internal funds to equity funding to debt funding. Match funding sources to needs.

I am bootstrapping - Creating an operational business with little start-up capital. Requires discipline, creativity and focus.

Return on Investment (ROI) - A measure of profit generated per unit of investment. ROI determines the attractiveness of potential investments.

Sunk Cost: A cost that has already been incurred and cannot be recovered. Sunk costs should not influence future decision making.

Internal Controls: Processes and safeguards that minimize loss due to error, fraud, and unreliable data. Vital for managing risks.

Caveman Syndrome: Humans tend to favor instant gratification over long-term benefits, driven by primitive evolutionary motivations—a core challenge in business and life.

Performance Requirements - The key outputs necessary for a role. Defining performance requirements makes expectations clear.

Onion Brain - The layered structure of the human brain, with primitive aspects at the core and more advanced functions at the periphery. Explains many irrational behaviors.

Perceptual Control - Adjusting perspectives to influence motivation and emotions. A powerful tool for managing yourself.

Reference Level: The baseline for comparisons that heavily influences perceptions. Reference levels explain many consumer behaviors.

Conservation of Energy - The tendency to seek to expend the least amount of mental and physical effort. Drives many human behaviors.

Guiding Structure - An established process for making good decisions consistently over time. Essential for complex undertakings.

Reorganization - Restructuring roles, systems, and incentives within a business. An essential tool for solving many business problems.

Pattern Matching - The tendency to interpret new information based on similarities to past experiences. Speeds understanding but causes bias.

Mental Simulation - Imagining and playing out scenarios in the mind. A low-cost way to prepare for many possibilities.

Interpretation/Reinterpretation - Assigning meaning to situations. Different interpretations of the same events are familiar sources of conflict.

Loss Aversion - The tendency to prefer avoiding losses over acquiring gains. Causes inconsistent decision making.

Threat Lockdown: Entering a highly focused state in response to a perceived danger that restricts higher cognition. Impairs judgment and decision making.

Cognitive Scope Limitation - The inability to consider possibilities outside one’s mental framework or perspective. Causes blindness to solutions.

Association - Connecting a stimulus to a pleasurable or painful response. Drives habit formation.

Absence Blindness - Failing to notice the absence of something. Causes neglect of critical gaps.

Contrast: Perceptions are influenced by relative differences from surroundings, not absolute qualities. Important for marketing.

Scarcity: Perceiving something as more valuable when its availability is limited. Drives many purchasing behaviors.

Novelty - The tendency to give more attention to something new and different. Important for innovation.

Akrasia: Struggling or failing to take actions you intend to take and believe are beneficial. Willpower alone is often insufficient.

Monoidealism - Becoming overly focused on a single goal, to the detriment of overall performance. Avoiding monoidealism improves results.

Cognitive Switching Penalty - Requiring mental effort and time to change between tasks. Batching similar tasks improves efficiency.

Four Methods of Completion: Clarifying desired outcomes and specifying necessary actions are essential to completing ambitious undertakings.

Most Important Tasks (MITs) - Focusing on mission-critical tasks with the highest value and priority is critical to achieving the most meaningful results.

Goals: Clarifying and focusing on the results you wish to achieve. Essential for motivation and decision making.

States of Being - Your physical, mental, and emotional state dramatically impacts your productivity. Actively managing your state is essential.

Habits - Behaviors performed automatically in response to cues. Habits can be shaped to support goals.

Priming: Exposure to a stimulus influences response to subsequent stimuli. Priming oneself strategically can be productive.

Decision - Making a definite choice from multiple alternatives based on clear criteria. High-quality decisions drive business success.

Five-Fold Why - Understanding root causes by repeatedly asking “Why?” Helpful in solving problems.

Five-Fold How - Mapping out an operational plan by asking “How?” Essential for executing ambitious undertakings.

Following Action - The very next physical activity required to move the process forward—the key to getting started and making progress.

Externalization - Converting ideas from mental representations to concrete forms outside the mind. Enables analysis, sharing, and realization of ideas.

Self-Elicitation - Strategically posing questions to prompt productive thinking. A simple method to stimulate insights.

Thought Experiment - Imagining hypothetical scenarios as a low-cost way to prepare for multiple possibilities.

Parkinson’s Law: Work tends to fill the time allotted. Setting tight deadlines spurs focus and productivity.

Doomsday Scenario - Considering worst-case scenarios highlights overlooked risks and generates contingency plans.

Excessive Self-Regard Tendency - The tendency to emphasize too much on one’s perspectives. Causes many judgment errors.

Confirmation Bias: The tendency to seek, interpret and create information that confirms existing beliefs. Causes narrow-mindedness.

Hindsight Bias: The tendency to see past events as more predictable than they were. This implies more control than exists.

Performance Load - The total demands on a situation’s mental and physical capacity. Overload causes strain and errors.

Energy Cycles - Fluctuations in motivation, focus, and alertness throughout the day. Aligning work with energy cycles improves productivity.

Stress and Recovery - Work strains mental and physical capacities, necessitating recovery periods to replenish resources and function effectively. Getting sufficient recovery is essential for sustainability.

Testing - Systematically gathering information to reduce uncertainty and validate assumptions. Critical for developing effective solutions.

Mystique - Maintaining an air of complexity and exclusivity around specialized knowledge. I am used to claiming excessive value. It should be demystified through education.

Hedonic Treadmill - The tendency for happiness to return to a baseline level despite changes in circumstances. Satisfaction depends on mindset, not external conditions.

Comparison Fallacy - Judging something based on a misleading comparison, omitting critical contextual factors. Causes misperceptions.

Locus of Control: The degree to which someone believes outcomes are within or outside their influence. Internality aids achievement.

Attachment - Linking identity and self-worth to external things. Causes painful loss when separated.

Personal Research and Development (R&D) - Regularly investing time and money in acquiring new capabilities keeps skills relevant and marketable.

Limiting Belief: A belief that limits accomplishment and opportunity. Identifying and rejecting limiting beliefs aids growth.

Malinvestment: Poor allocation of time, money, or effort that does not yield sufficient benefit. Avoiding malinvestment improves ROI.

Necessity of Choice: Committing to a specific option necessarily requires missing benefits of alternatives. But not deciding is a choice with opportunity cost.

Arrival Fallacy: Assuming a goal, once achieved, will provide lasting satisfaction. Fulfillment comes from the process, not just the result.

Power - The capability to influence the thoughts and behaviors of others. Multiple kinds of power operate in business.

Comparative Advantage: Focusing your efforts where you deliver the most value relative to others. Enables mutually beneficial cooperation.

Communication Overhead - The burden created by processes intended to foster understanding between people. Minimizing overhead improves efficiency.

Importance: The degree to which a person’s involvement impacts the outcome. Allocate interactions accordingly.

Safety - Freedom from fear of negative consequences for reasonable missteps. People perform better in safe environments.

Golden Trifecta - Competence, trustworthiness and concern for others. The foundation for likability and influence.

Reason Why - Providing the logic behind requests and decisions. Reason why aligns and motivates.

She earned Regard - Genuine appreciation and respect derived from demonstrated character and competence over time. The most influential type of regard.

Bystander Apathy: Diffusion of responsibility when people assume someone else will take action. Speaking up mobilizes others.

Planning Fallacy - The tendency to underestimate the time and resources required to complete tasks. Allowing buffers mitigates.

It is a forcing Function - A situation requiring action that overcomes inertia or delay. Helpful in ensuring needed actions.

Referrals - Leveraging satisfied customers and associates to spread positive word of mouth. Highly effective marketing.

Clanning - Group identification around interests and attributes. Clans provide support, purpose and incentives.

Convergence - Moving toward agreement. Helpful in making group decisions.

Divergence - Generating distinct options through varied perspectives and approaches. Critical before converging.

Social Proof - Relying on the behavior of others to determine appropriate action. Causes herding behavior.

Authority: The perception that someone should be obeyed. People tend to comply with authority figures.

Commitment and Consistency - The tendency to follow through on explicit commitments and act consistently with prior decisions. Creates integrity and predictability.

Incentive-Caused Bias: Tendency to favor options providing financial and other advantages. Clouds judgment on merits.

Modal Bias: Judging the likelihood of events based on their ability to recall. Causes distortion.

Attribution Error - Misjudging the relative influence of personal disposition versus situational factors in causing behaviors. Causes biased judgments about responsibility.

Mind-Reading Fallacy: Assuming you know the beliefs, motivations, and reasoning behind others’ actions. Causes misunderstanding.

Boundary Setting - Defining acceptable and unacceptable behaviors to build constructive relationships.

Principle of Charity - Interpreting others’ statements and actions in the best possible light before judging. Reduces conflict.

Option Orientation: Presenting choices when directing others boosts motivation and satisfaction.

Management - Planning, optimizing, and controlling business systems, processes, and people. Essential for scaling operations.

Performance-Based Hiring - Selecting new team members based on demonstrated ability to complete actual work tasks. Improves quality of hires.

Gall’s Law: Complex functional systems arise from simple rules. Understanding the rules reveals points of leverage.

Flow - The movement of people, information, or goods over time. Optimizing flow improves productivity.

Stock - An accumulation of materials or information at a point in time. Levels affect downstream flow.

Slack: Unused resources that cushion against variability and disruption. Some slack aids stability.

Constraint: A bottleneck that limits throughput. Alleviating constraints is crucial in improving flow.

Feedback Loop: Causal chains where output becomes input, causing amplification or regulation. Feedback enables learning and control.

Autocatalysis: A feedback loop where growth feeds on itself. It drives exponential expansion.

Environment: External conditions and players that influence outcomes. Monitoring relevant environments provides valuable information.

Selection Test: A challenge that rewards those with the necessary qualities and filters out the rest. Reveals capabilities.

Entropy - The tendency for concentrated order to degrade into disorder over time without energy inputs. Requires ongoing counteraction.

Uncertainty - Lack of complete predictability about the future. Strategies like testing and Slack manage uncertainty.

Change - Shifts in behaviors, perceptions or systems over time. Expect and plan for change.

Interdependence - Mutual dependence between elements of a system. Parts affect the whole.

Counterparty Risk - Potential loss exposure from the failure of the other party in an agreement to meet obligations. Requires trust or guarantees.

Second-Order Effects - Consequences of consequences. Long causal chains link distal events. Consider second-order effects when intervening.

Externality - A cost or benefit incurred by a party not involved in the transaction causing it. Often calls for systemic solutions.

Normal Accidents - Unavoidable meltdowns in complex systems. Preparation, containment, and recovery capabilities mitigate damage.

Deconstruction: Breaking a process down into steps to understand how it works. Deconstruction enables improvement and problem solving.

Measurement - Quantifying observations. Allows tracking trends, catching problems early and testing changes.

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) - A small set of clearly-defined, quantifiable metrics that reflect strategic performance. Focuses improvement efforts.

Garbage In, Garbage Out: Faulty inputs produce faulty outputs. Accurate, high-quality data is essential.

Tolerance - The acceptable range of variation from a target. Wider tolerance permits greater flexibility but less precision.

Variance - Inconsistency between observations of a metric. High variance signals unpredictability.

Analytical Honesty - Letting the evidence guide analysis to valuable conclusions, rather than distorting analysis to support predetermined conclusions. Critical thinking requires analytical honesty.

Context - The circumstances and factors surrounding an event. Context is crucial for helpful interpretation.

Sampling - Selecting a representative portion of a population to observe. Clever sampling provides sufficient understanding efficiently.

The margin of Error - The potential inaccuracy inherent in extrapolating from a sample to a population. Disclosures build trust.

Ratio - A proportional relationship between quantities. Ratios quantify connections and enable benchmarking.

Typicality: How well a sample represents a population. High typicality supports generalizing findings.

Correlation - A mutual relationship between occurrences. Correlation does not necessarily indicate causation.

Causation: When one event reliably causes another event. Understanding causation enables control and prediction.

Norms - Common or expected ranges, behaviors, or practices. Norms provide context for evaluating observations.

Proxy: An observable factor that reliably corresponds to a factor that cannot be directly observed. Proxies enable the measurement of abstract factors.

Segmentation - Dividing a broad population into subgroups with everyday needs or attributes. Allows customized appeals.

Humanization - Personalizing and adding emotive qualities to objects and data. Humanization fosters engagement and interest. But can also distort thinking.

Intervention Bias - Attempting action before comprehensively analyzing the problem. Risks misguided effort and unintended consequences.

Optimization - Improving performance by systematically applying knowledge to adjust inputs and processes. Optimization leverages improvements.

Refactoring - Restructuring systems to improve operation without changing essential functions. Enables ongoing improvement.

Critical Few: The small number of elements that account for most results. Focus on the critical few substantially improve outcomes.

Diminishing Returns - The tendency for benefits gained from repeated actions to decline over time. Shifting strategy counters diminishing returns.

Progressive Load - Increasing demands gradually over time. Allows capacity expansion while minimizing strain.

Friction: Forces that inhibit motion and flow through systems. Reducing friction improves efficiency.

Automation - Accomplishing tasks through technology instead of manual effort. Automation improves consistency and leverage.

Paradox of Automation: The more efficient a system, the more critical human attention becomes for handling exceptions and disturbances. Humans ensure integrity.

The irony of Automation: Adding complexity to avoid complexity often makes systems trickier for humans, undermining reliability gains. Could you keep it simple?

Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) - Step-by-step instructions for completing essential tasks consistently and efficiently. Good SOPs capture best practices.

Checklist - A list of required steps to ensure proper completion of an undertaking. Checklists prevent oversights.

Process Overhead - Additional efforts required by processes themselves. Minimizing overhead maximizes output.

Cessation - Completely stopping unproductive activities frees up resources for more beneficial applications.

Resilience - The capacity to bounce back from challenges and setbacks. Resilience enables sustained high performance.

Fail-safes: Automatic provisions that prevent or limit damage in cases of failure or error. Fail-safes enable stable functioning.

Stress Testing - Simulating challenging conditions to evaluate performance. Improves preparedness and exposes weaknesses.

Scenario Planning - Developing plans and strategies to manage plausible future events. Broaden’s options for a decisive response.

Exploration/Exploitation - Allocating resources between exploring new options and exploiting existing certainties. Balance expands possibilities.

Sustainable Growth Cycle: Improving a system until limits are reached, then redesigning it at a new level. Repeated redesign sustains growth.

Middle Path - Finding a stable, sustainable balance between extremes. The middle path integrates competing concerns.

Experimental mindset - Continuously testing and improving through rapid iterative cycles. Maximizes learning and progress.

Not “The End” - Viewing setbacks as learning experiences, not failures. Persistence and resilience overcome obstacles.

Here is a summary of the key points in the preface and introduction to The Personal MBA by Josh Kaufman:

  • The book provides a practical, efficient way to build a solid understanding of general business principles without needing an MBA or other formal business education.

  • Core business concepts allow you to identify opportunities, make good decisions, start a business, get promoted, or improve an existing business.

  • You don’t need to know everything about business - grasp the fundamental principles. This scaffolding makes it easier to build knowledge and make progress.

  • The book aims to provide the top 1% of business knowledge needed for success by filtering out unnecessary complexity.

  • Key barriers the book helps overcome: fear of the unknown (“business angst”), belief that business is only for credentialed experts (“certification intimidation”), and feeling unqualified (“impostor syndrome”).

  • Real business success comes from applying universal principles rather than memorizing situational methods. The book focuses on enduring fundamentals.

  • The concepts apply to any field or endeavor, not just traditional business. The skills help you accomplish personal goals.

  • The book condenses a broad topic into an accessible, actionable volume you can read in a few hours. It’s a starting point if more research is needed.

  • This book is optional for prior business knowledge or experience. The concepts presented will give you a solid framework for making sound business decisions, whether you are just starting or are an experienced executive.

  • The book focuses on teaching essential business concepts called “mental models” rather than specific techniques or answers. Accurate mental models allow you to think clearly and make better decisions.

  • The author created this “Personal MBA” as an alternative to a traditional MBA program. After getting a corporate job offer usually reserved for MBA graduates, he self-educated by reading extensively about business instead of pursuing a formal degree.

  • With no prior business experience beyond working at his family’s small farm, the author was thrust into the complex corporate world at Procter & Gamble. This motivated him to create his business curriculum by reading hundreds of books to gain the knowledge an MBA would provide.

  • The Personal MBA aims to learn the essential business concepts to focus time and energy on creating value rather than worrying about lacking knowledge or credentials.

  • The author worked at Procter & Gamble after college, educating himself on business topics through extensive reading rather than getting an MBA. He was doing well at P&G but grew frustrated with corporate bureaucracy.

  • The author created a reading list of the best business books as a personal project. The list went viral after being featured by Seth Godin and major media outlets.

  • The reading list garnered global interest, leading the author to quit his job and pursue the “Personal MBA” full-time. However, he realized more than just providing a reading list was needed.

  • The author was inspired by Charlie Munger’s approach of using “mental models” - powerful concepts from multiple disciplines - rather than formal education. This led him to distill the key ideas from all the books into a framework of core business concepts.

  • The Personal MBA framework empowers people to educate themselves on the most helpful business knowledge. The author left his job to focus on researching, writing, and spreading these ideas.

In summary, the Personal MBA evolved from a personal reading list project into a global phenomenon based on identifying and sharing the essential business concepts without the time and expense of graduate school.

  • Charlie Munger is Warren Buffett’s long-time business partner at Berkshire Hathaway. Together, their mental model-based approach to business led to enormous success.

  • Munger never formally studied business but educated himself across disciplines to build a “latticework of mental models.” He applied these models to make skilled business decisions.

  • The author studied Munger’s mental models to understand how successful businesses work.

  • Businesses create value, meet customer needs, enable transactions, deliver satisfaction, and generate sufficient profit. Underlying this are concepts from psychology, neuroscience, and systems thinking.

  • The author tested these principles with clients and readers, helping them improve their careers, launch businesses faster, and create more value.

  • For skeptics, the author argues traditional MBA programs have become overpriced, overcrowded, and outdated. Self-education focused on fundamental principles is presented as a superior alternative.

  • MBA programs are expensive, with top programs costing over $200,000 for the full degree. This requires taking on significant debt that takes years to pay off.

  • MBA programs do not guarantee high-paying jobs or business skills. Experience is needed to develop management and leadership abilities.

  • Much of the curriculum focuses on complex financial models and statistics rather than practical business knowledge. Graduates often realize they need to gain the business knowledge needed for success.

  • Admissions favor wealthy, well-connected applicants who are likelier to get high-paying jobs. Schools take credit for these students’ success rather than creating it.

  • Studies show MBAs provide little career benefit compared to other masters degrees. Business skills are learned through experience, not in the classroom.

  • An MBA is optional to start a successful business or have a high-paying career. Alternative options like self-education are cheaper and teach more relevant skills.

  • Overall, the high costs and questionable benefits mean an MBA may not be worth pursuing for many people. Hands-on experience and self-education are often better paths to business success and financial security.

  • Pfeffer and Fong found that possessing an MBA degree and grades earned in business school have little to no correlation with career success, questioning the value of an MBA.

  • There needs to be more evidence that MBA curriculum and research impact real-world management practices.

  • Getting an MBA, particularly from a non-elite school, has no relationship with higher salaries or attaining higher positions. An MBA may take over a decade to break even financially.

  • MBA programs teach concepts only very applicable to some actual business jobs. They were designed for managing large industrial operations, not today’s diverse business world.

  • There’s no evidence MBA credentials or grades predict better performance as CEOs or executives. Situational factors matter far more.

  • Early business schools focused on scientific management, efficiency, incentives, and distribution. Finance grew increasingly complex statistically. These origins shape curriculums even now despite the changed business landscape.

  • In summary, the disconnect between classical business school teachings and the needs of the modern workplace, along with the need for evidence that an MBA boosts career success, raises serious questions about the value of typical MBA programs today.

  • Business schools teach financial models and theories that need to be updated, revised, or reflect how modern businesses operate. They emphasize quantitative analysis over real-world business operations.

  • MBAs focus on short-term profits and financial engineering instead of long-term value creation. This has led to the gutting of viable companies.

  • Small businesses now represent the majority of firms and job creation, but business schools still cater to big corporations.

  • The main benefit of MBA programs is access to recruiters at big companies, consulting firms, and banks. The credential gets your foot in the door but matters less after 3-5 years.

  • MBA debt burdens graduates, forcing them to take high-paying but demanding corporate jobs they may not enjoy to pay off loans.

  • Business schools have little incentive to change if students keep applying. They preserve the problem they claim to solve.

  • For most people, the costs and time of an MBA outweigh the benefits. Unless you must work at a top consulting/finance firm, an MBA is unnecessary for career success.

Here are a few critical points about value creation from the passage:

  • The purpose of every business is to create value by improving someone else’s life. Businesses identify unmet needs and find ways to provide solutions.

  • Value can take different forms, but the goal is always the same - to improve people’s lives. A business must create value to exist.

  • The most successful businesses create the most value for others. Some create a little value for many people, others create a lot of value for a few.

  • A successful business is a repeatable process that: (1) Creates/delivers value, (2) That people want/need, (3) At a price they’ll pay, (4) In a way that satisfies them, (5) generate profit to sustain the business.

  • The more accurate value a business creates, the more successful it will become. Value creation is critical.

The passage emphasizes that identifying unmet needs, creating solutions that improve lives, and delivering real value to others is central to business success. The more value created, the better.

  • Successful businesses satisfy core human drives like acquiring things, bonding with others, learning, defending ourselves, and feeling pleasure.

  • First, people satisfy basic needs like food and shelter (existence), then relationships (relatedness), then personal growth (growth).

  • Creating valuable marketing, sales, delivery, and finance skills helps a business succeed. Focus on skills that help you create economic value.

  • Businesses only succeed if there is market demand for their offering. Research the market before starting a business.

  • The five parts of every business are value creation, marketing, sales, value delivery, and finance. A viable business needs all five.

  • Skills and knowledge are only economically valuable if applied to create value, attract customers, make sales, deliver products/services, or manage finances.

The key is to identify an underserved human drive or need, validate market demand, then build skills to serve that market profitably. Satisfying core human drives with an economically viable offering is the foundation of a successful business.

Here are the critical points about evaluating markets and competition:

  • Before starting a new business, evaluate the market’s urgency, size, pricing potential, customer acquisition cost, value delivery cost, uniqueness, speed to market, upfront investment, upsell, and evergreen potential. Markets that score over 75 are up-and-coming.

  • Don’t avoid markets just because they have competition - competition validates there are paying customers and lets you observe what works before committing to a strategy. Become a customer of competitors to learn about the market.

  • Don’t start a business just for money - find a market that interests you enough to keep improving your offering daily. Pay attention to what you keep coming back to.

  • “Boring” businesses can be very lucrative if they serve an attractive market. Please don’t ignore them before investigating further.

  • To stand out from the competition, either be the lowest cost provider or differentiate yourself by focusing on a niche, improving the product/service, or enhancing the customer experience.

  • Competition forces innovation and improvement. It gives customers more options and makes the market more efficient.

  • Don’t get discouraged by competition. Use it as motivation to build something that serves customers’ needs. Every successful business had competition.

Here are the key points from the passages:

The Mercenary Rule

  • Mundane or “dirty” businesses like plumbing and garbage collection may not be glamorous. Still, they can be quite lucrative because there is high demand and relatively few people willing to meet that demand.

  • If you can find a way to make a necessary but dull field interesting enough to pursue, you may discover a profitable niche waiting to be tapped.

The Crusader Rule

  • It’s easy to get overly enthusiastic about an idea you find fascinating, but evaluating it objectively as a potential business is essential.

  • Test the market thoroughly before fully committing, as changing the world is difficult if you can’t pay the bills. Pursue passion projects as side hustles until you have financial security.

Twelve Standard Forms of Value

  • Businesses provide value in one or more of 12 standard forms: product, service, shared resource, subscription, resale, lease, agency, audience aggregation, loan, option, insurance, and capital.

  • Each form has its requirements and economics. Products can be duplicated; services depend on time investment; shared resources require careful capacity management, etc.

  • Choosing the correct form(s) of value is critical to developing a viable business model.

Here is a summary of the key points about each form of value:

  1. Product: Create something valuable and sell instances of it. Focus on usefulness, quality, and meeting customer needs.

  2. Service: Do valuable things for others they can’t or don’t want to do themselves. Focus on reducing effort and creating results.

  3. Shared Resource: Acquire an asset, then allow others to use it. Manage usage to maximize yield. Focus on utilization and availability.

  4. Subscription: Provide ongoing value regularly for a recurring fee. Focus on retention and minimizing attrition.

  5. Resale: Buy at wholesale prices, sell at retail prices. Focus on sourcing, inventory management, and maximizing markup.

  6. Lease: Allow temporary usage of an asset in exchange for a fee. Focus on maximizing yield before the asset loses value.

  7. Agency: Connect buyers and sellers and collect a percentage. Focus on making connections and closing deals.

  8. Audience Aggregation: Collect a specific audience, then sell access to that audience. Focus on delivering value to the audience to retain them.

Here are the critical points about Hassle Premium:

  • People are often willing to pay to avoid hassles or tasks they find too difficult, time-consuming, or annoying to handle.

  • Hassles come in many forms - time-consuming, frustrating, requiring specialized skills, etc.

  • Businesses can charge a “Hassle Premium” by handling these hassles for customers.

  • Examples include cleaning services, delivery services, assembly services, technical support, and more.

  • The more frustrating or time-consuming a task is, the more people will pay to avoid doing it themselves.

  • Business models built around eliminating hassles for customers can be very profitable if priced right.

  • The key is to identify hassles many people experience and would gladly pay to avoid, then build a business around solving that hassle.

The main idea is that hassles represent business opportunities if you can eliminate the hassle for customers and charge a premium. Identifying and solving customer hassles can lead to successful business models.

Here is a summary of the key points about creating value:

  • You can provide twelve standard forms of value: products, services, shared resources, subscriptions, resale, interest, insurance, capital, options, communities, audiences, and labor.

  • Focus on satisfying core human drives like novelty, social contact, and achievement. Solve pressing problems and frustrations.

  • Reduce hassle and complexity for the end user. Charge a “hassle premium” for taking on unwanted tasks.

  • Increase perceived value by satisfying drives, offering clear benefits, reducing hassle, and providing status.

  • Use modularity - combine different forms of value in different ways. Bundle offers together or unbundle into separate parts.

  • Act as an intermediary to help buyers or disintermediate by connecting buyers and sellers directly.

  • Rapidly test ideas by creating prototypes, scaling up what shows promise, and discontinuing what doesn’t work.

  • Leverage strategic assets like proprietary technology, scale, brand reputation, and distribution systems.

  • Partner with other companies to share access to each other’s assets and customers.

  • Continuously improve by testing, measuring, and optimizing based on customer feedback and data.

  • Don’t get overly obsessed with secrecy and non-disclosure agreements when developing a new product or business idea. Ideas alone have little value - the key is executing the idea.

  • Get customer feedback early and often by creating prototypes and showing potential customers your work in progress. Their feedback will help shape and improve your offering.

  • Use the iteration cycle of observing, experimenting, collecting data, evaluating results, and deciding whether to accept changes to improve your offering rapidly—faster iteration velocity results in faster improvement.

  • Ask open-ended questions and listen to customer feedback, even if it is critical. Feedback helps you understand if your offering meets customer needs and identifies barriers to purchase.

  • Let potential customers preorder or “shadow test” your offering to gauge actual demand and willingness to pay. If only some people commit to a preorder, you must refine your offering further.

  • Committing to an offering and pushing forward is better than endless hesitancy and analysis. The key is rapidly testing ideas in the market to validate demand and improve based on feedback.

Here is a summarized version of the key points:

  • Trade-offs are necessary because time, energy, and resources are finite. You can only have some things, so prioritize what matters most.

  • Customers choose offerings based on economic values like efficacy, speed, reliability, ease of use, flexibility, status, aesthetic appeal, emotion, and cost.

  • Offerings can emphasize either convenience (speed, reliability, ease, flexibility) or fidelity (quality, status, aesthetics, emotion). Successful offerings optimize for one or the other.

  • To determine what people value, use relative importance testing - ask people to make trade-offs and choices between options with different combinations of features and attributes. This reveals what they genuinely prioritize.

  • Perfection isn’t possible - people will be satisfied with the next best alternative that delivers on their most important values. Focus on improving key attributes rather than trying to excel at everything.

  • Different customer segments have different values. Identify patterns in what your best potential customers value when making trade-offs. Optimize your offering for those key attributes.

  • Critical Assumptions are the key facts or characteristics that must be true for a business or offering to succeed. If these assumptions prove false, the business idea will fail.

  • Identifying and testing Critical Assumptions is essential before fully committing to a business idea. This allows you to minimize risk.

  • Shadow Testing involves selling an offering before it is fully developed to test Critical Assumptions with real customers. This provides valuable feedback on whether people will pay for the offering.

  • A Minimum Viable Offer provides just enough to elicit an actual sale. This allows you to start testing with real customers without fully developing the offering.

  • Fitbit used Shadow Testing and a Minimum Viable Offer (prototype, description, renderings) to validate demand and raise funds before developing their product.

  • The hypothetical yoga studio example illustrates creating a Minimum Viable Offer website to Shadow Test willingness to pay membership fees. This reduces risk before committing to a lease.

  • Overall, identifying Critical Assumptions, Shadow Testing them with a Minimum Viable Offer, and using genuine customer feedback lets you refine and validate your business idea before fully launching. This approach reduces risk and increases the chances of success.

  • Marketing is essential for any business to attract prospects interested in your offer. No one will know about or want to buy your products/services without marketing.

  • Marketing involves getting attention and generating interest. It is different from sales, which is about closing deals.

  • In an attention economy, attention is limited. To earn attention, you must be more exciting or valuable than competitors.

  • More than getting attention is required - you need qualified, high-quality attention from prospects likely to buy. Mass attention has little value.

  • Effective marketing cuts through the noise to connect with qualified prospects. It provides value and earns attention.

  • There are many marketing channels to reach prospects - advertising, social media, content marketing, referrals, etc. Choosing the right channel(s) is critical.

  • Testing and iterating are critical in marketing to see what works. Measure results and double down on what attracts qualified prospects cost-effectively.

  • Marketing and sales work together to generate interest, convert prospects to customers, complete transactions, and build relationships.

  • People ignore what they don’t care about. Receptivity is a measure of how open someone is to your message. Match the medium to what they care about when they are most receptive.

  • Remarkability - make your offer stand out and violate expectations to attract attention. Be unique and pique curiosity.

  • Focus on Probable Purchasers - those most likely to buy what you offer. Only try to appeal to some.

  • Break Preoccupation - divert attention from what they are already focused on by provoking curiosity, surprise, or concern.

  • Move prospects through the Levels of Awareness - unaware, aware, informed, interested, desirous, purchaser. Guide them from not knowing you exist to buying from you.

  • Get attention the right way through usefulness and value, not gimmicks. Earn attention by actually helping people.

The key is attracting prospects at the right time by offering something remarkable, valuable, and relevant to their interests. Move them through increasing levels of awareness until they become purchasers.

  • Focus marketing on the desired result or experience the customer wants, not just product features. Connect to core human drives.

  • Demonstrating the product/service in action is very effective marketing, as it builds belief by showing how well it works.

  • Qualify prospects beforehand to determine if they are a good fit, minimizing wasted time on the wrong customers. Turn away prospects that will not be profitable.

  • Enter the market where there is already interest and awareness of the problem to be solved. Indifference is very hard to overcome.

  • Guide the prospect through the natural progression of awareness, from being unaware of the problem to being ready to purchase the solution—match messaging to their current level.

  • Educate the prospect on why the offer is in their interest. Create belief in the benefits and move them closer to purchasing.

The main ideas are demonstrating value, qualifying ideal customers, targeting existing interests, and educating prospects by meeting them at their current level of awareness. Good marketing connects to human motivations and moves people logically through the buying journey.

  • Effective marketing makes prospects want what you’re offering by connecting with their preexisting desires. You can’t force people to want something; you can only show how your offer fulfills their desires.

  • Connecting your offer to the Core Human Drives is an excellent way to tap into basic desires. The more drives you appeal to, the more effective your marketing.

  • Getting prospects to visualize using your product or service is very powerful. Test drives, demos, samples, etc., let people experience what owning the product would feel like, making them want it more.

  • Vivid sensory experiences like test drives make it easier for people to imagine the benefits of owning the product. They’re much more likely to buy once they visualize and want it.

  • Your job as a marketer isn’t to manipulate desires but to show how your offer fulfills the desires prospects already have. Help them convince themselves your offer will get them what they want.

  • Framing is emphasizing specific details while minimizing others when communicating information. It helps present information persuasively without overwhelming people with too many facts.

  • Framing is not lying or deceit. It should compellingly present truthful information. Misrepresenting information will undermine trust and reputation.

  • Offering something valuable for free attracts attention and new customers. It allows people to experience your value without commitment. But free offerings should lead to paid sales.

  • Asking for permission to follow up and provide more value is more effective than interrupting people with unsolicited messages. Permission marketing builds relationships with interested prospects.

  • Use it respectfully to continue providing relevant value once you have permission. Don’t spam people with irrelevant information or overuse the privilege.

Here is a summary of the key points about attention-grabbing marketing techniques:

  • Hooks are short phrases that highlight the main benefit of an offer to grab attention. Good hooks are clear and concise, emphasizing what makes an offer uniquely valuable.

  • Calls to action explicitly tell prospects what simple action to take next, like visiting a website or purchasing. Effective CTAs are apparent and ask for a sale or permission to follow up.

  • Narratives tell stories prospects want to hear, like testimonials or “hero’s journey” tales where customers overcome challenges. Vivid stories attract attention.

  • Controversy publicly takes a stand that not everyone agrees with. As long as it’s not needlessly inflammatory, controversy can attract attention and spread the word of an offer.

  • Social proof shows an offer is credible by highlighting others who have purchased or endorsed it. People pay more attention to offers validated by others.

  • Conspicuous consumption uses luxury products to signal status and wealth. Expensive branding attracts attention and perceived prestige.

  • A transaction is an exchange of value between parties. Businesses survive by bringing in more money than they spend through transactions.

  • You can only transact economically valuable things. Develop and test a minimum viable offer to ensure it’s valuable before investing significantly.

  • Trust between parties is essential for a transaction to occur. Customers will only pay if they believe you can deliver what you promise. Build trust by dealing fairly and honestly over time.

  • Find common ground - overlapping interests between you and the customer. Sales aren’t about convincing people to do something not in their interest. Align interests to find common ground.

  • Understand what your probable purchasers want or need. Make your offer easy to accept and understand how it benefits the customer.

  • Be patient and helpful during the sales process. Guide prospects through the buying process. Remove barriers and objections that stand in the way of a transaction.

  • The Pricing Uncertainty Principle states that all prices are arbitrary and can change anytime. You must be able to justify your pricing to customers.

  • Four standard pricing methods:

  1. Replacement cost: What would it cost to recreate the item? Add margin.

  2. Market comparison: What are similar items selling for?

  3. Discounted cash flow/Net present value: What is the item worth based on projected cash flows?

  4. Value comparison: How much is the item worth to a specific buyer based on unique characteristics?

  • Price Transition Shock: Changing prices affects the type of customer you attract. Raising prices can increase demand by targeting more attractive customers.

  • Understand how changing prices impacts different customer segments. Avoid drastic price changes unless necessary. Consider non-price changes like packaging and positioning first.

  • Value-Based Selling involves understanding what makes your offer valuable to the customer, then emphasizing those aspects during the sales process. It’s about listening to understand the customer’s needs rather than pushing your product.

  • Asking good questions helps identify how your product can solve the customer’s problems. This builds trust and helps justify your pricing.

  • Education-Based Selling involves teaching customers so they become better informed about your industry. This builds trust, turns them into ideal customers, and justifies higher pricing.

  • Knowing your Next Best Alternative - what you’ll do if you can’t reach an agreement - strengthens your negotiating position. The other party has a Next Best Alternative too.

  • You strengthen your position by improving your Next Best Alternative before negotiations. Be willing to walk away if needed to get a good deal.

  • Anchoring involves making the first bid to anchor expectations. Make an extreme but plausible opening bid, then compromise to something still favorable.

  • Framing is shaping the anchors and choices to influence decisions. Present a higher-priced premium option first to make a lower-priced option seem more reasonable.

The key ideas are understanding value, building trust through education, knowing your walk-away options, anchoring negotiations, and framing choices advantageously.

  • There are three dimensions to negotiation: setup, structure, and discussion.

  • Setup involves preparing the environment and context for the negotiation. Research who you are negotiating with, frame your proposal attractively and ensure the environment is conducive to a deal.

  • Structure involves putting together the terms of your proposal. Understand the other party’s needs, consider trade-offs you’re willing to make, and anticipate potential objections.

  • Discussion is presenting the offer and negotiating the details. Be flexible and focus on finding common ground.

  • Effective negotiation requires preparation in all three dimensions: set up the context, structure a firm offer, then discuss to reach an agreement. Doing the work before the discussion increases the odds of a good outcome.

Here are the critical points on Reciprocation:

  • Reciprocation is people’s strong desire to “payback” favors, gifts, benefits, and resources provided to them. You feel compelled to return the favor if someone does something nice for you.

  • This principle can be used in sales and marketing. Providing free samples, discounts, or other benefits creates a feeling of obligation to purchase from you.

  • However, Reciprocation must be used ethically. Do not provide excessive benefits that feel manipulative. The benefits should be meaningful but not over the top.

  • People also reciprocate negative actions. If you harm someone, they will feel compelled to harm you back. This can start a cycle of escalating retaliation.

  • When used appropriately, Reciprocation is a powerful principle that builds relationships and goodwill. Ensure you only use it to provide genuine value, not to manipulate it.

  • Give benefits unconditionally, without apparent strings attached. This makes the receiver more likely to reciprocate voluntarily out of obligation and appreciation.

Does this help summarize the key ideas about Reciprocation? Let me know if you need any clarification or have additional questions!

Here are the critical points for overcoming barriers to purchase:

  • When a prospect says “no,” don’t give up. There’s always a reason behind the objection. Identify and address their concerns to close the sale.

  • The five common objections are: it costs too much, it won’t work, it won’t work for me, I can wait, it’s too complicated. Anticipate and mitigate these upfront.

  • Address “it costs too much” with framing and value-based selling. Show how the value far exceeds the price.

  • Address “it won’t work/won’t work for me” with social proof - testimonials from similar customers.

  • Address “I can wait/too difficult” with education-based selling. Teach them about problems they may not realize they have.

  • Once you have their attention and interest, ask questions to uncover the natural barriers behind “no.” Remove objections by demonstrating how you address their concerns.

  • Persistently chip away at objections while keeping the conversation positive. Build value and trust. Eliminate barriers and close the sale.

Here is a summary of the key points about Value Delivery:

Value Stream

  • A value stream is creating and delivering a product or service to the end customer.
  • It starts with raw materials and ends with the finished product in the hands of the customer.
  • Understanding and optimizing the value stream is critical for delivering value efficiently.


  • A bottleneck is a value stream step limiting the overall throughput or capacity.
  • Identifying and eliminating bottlenecks can significantly increase productivity and delivery speed.

Demand-Pull System

  • A demand-pull system produces output based on customer demand instead of forecasts.
  • This reduces overproduction and excess inventory, which helps improve cash flow.
  • Pull systems are more responsive and flexible than traditional “push” systems.

Inventory Management

  • Good inventory management balances the costs of carrying inventory with the costs of stockouts.
  • Just-in-time inventory systems time deliveries to arrive when needed, minimizing inventory.
  • ABC analysis focuses inventory investment on high-value SKUs instead of all products equally.

Order Management

  • Order management handles receiving, tracking, fulfillment, billing, returns, etc., for orders.
  • Well-designed systems and processes are crucial for accurately delivering orders.
  • Automation via e-commerce platforms or integration software can optimize order management.

Customer Service

  • Good customer service retains customers, creates loyalty, and improves reputation and referrals.
  • Service recovery policies for addressing problems distinguish average companies from great ones.
  • Empowering employees to satisfy customers often trumps strict policies and procedures.

In summary, efficiently delivering value to customers requires optimizing the entire value stream while providing excellent customer service. This builds loyalty, referrals, and repeat business.

Here is a summary of the key points about inventory:

  • Inventory refers to the stock of products a business has on hand. This includes raw materials, work-in-progress, and finished goods.

  • Inventory must be managed carefully to balance having enough to meet demand without unnecessarily tying up too much capital.

  • Businesses track inventory levels and turnover to optimize inventory management. A high turnover means inventory is selling quickly. Low turnover could indicate excess inventory or poor product-market fit.

  • Inventory goes through several steps from production to reaching the consumer, including being unwrapped, unboxed, placed on store shelves, and finally purchased.

  • Managing inventory efficiently through techniques like just-in-time manufacturing can improve operations and cash flow.

  • Overall, inventory management is a crucial aspect of business operations that allows companies to fulfill product demand effectively. Careful attention to inventory levels, turnover, and supply chain processes helps optimize it.

  • Throughput is the rate at which a system achieves its desired goal. It measures the effectiveness of a company’s value stream.

  • Throughput is calculated as units produced per unit of time. The higher the throughput, the better.

  • There are different types of throughput:

    • Dollar throughput - how fast a business makes a dollar of profit

    • Production throughput - how long it takes to produce each unit

    • Satisfaction throughput - how long it takes to produce a satisfied customer

  • Measuring throughput is the first step toward improving it. If you need to know your current throughput rates, make it a priority to find out.

  • Duplication is the ability to reproduce something of value, like using a factory to produce many copies of a product. It allows you to deliver your offer at scale in a cost-effective way.

  • Historically, duplication has made offerings like books more affordable and accessible by reducing the manual effort required to reproduce each unit.

Author Photo

About Matheus Puppe