SUMMARY - Natural-born Cyborgs _ Minds, Technologies - Clark, Andy_
Here is a summary of the key ideas:
• The human mind is not confined to the brain or body but incorporates external tools, props, and resources. We are “natural-born cyborgs” who constantly annex technological aids and environments into our cognitive systems.
• New technologies like AI, augmented reality, and brain-computer interfaces will push our cyborg natures to new levels. But humans have always relied on nonbiological resources to expand our intelligence. We did not evolve to operate based solely on the biological brain.
• What matters most for human-machine integration is how profoundly the technology can transform human experiences, projects, and capacities. Non-invasive technologies may offer the most potential for enhancement and symbiosis. Implants are not required.
• Ubiquitous computing environments and transparent technologies are becoming seamlessly integrated into our lives, to the point of becoming extensions of our minds and bodies. Cell phones and other digital tools exemplify this nonpenetrative cyborgism.
• Commercial aircraft show how technology can be deeply integrated into human cognition without implants. Pilots rely on automated systems and computers, turning them into temporary cyborgs. This model shows the potential for noninvasive human-machine merger.
• We underestimate how naturally we offload cognition onto nonbiological resources. Our problem-solving abilities emerge from interactions between biology, tools, and technology. We readily become “team players” with the technology we have at our disposal.
• Pens, language, mathematics, and other symbolic tools illustrate how we co-evolve with technology. These tools shape our thinking even as we shape them. They are not just aids but become inseparable from how we think, reason, and exist in the world.
• The line between mind and world was always porous. We are predisposed to change, prosthesis, extension, and transcendence of bodily and cognitive limits. Understanding human nature requires seeing us as moving targets, constantly reinventing ourselves through new tools and technology.
That covers the essence of the ideas around humans as natural-born cyborgs, the role of ubiquitous computing and transparent technologies in enhancing our lives, the potential for noninvasive human-machine integration, and how we constantly co-evolve with the tools and props we have at our disposal. The overall perspective is that human minds and intelligence emerge from the interaction of brain, body, and world, not the brain alone. We are fundamentally oriented toward expansion, prosthesis, and transcendence of limits through technology.
Here is a summary of the key ideas:
Software agents and interactive technologies are becoming increasingly integrated into human lives and even our sense of self. They have co-evolved with humans over time to become extensions of our minds.
Humans are biologically primed to incorporate external tools and technologies into our extended minds. Plasticity and social learning allow us to deeply integrate new resources into our thinking.
The merging of human minds and technology mirrors the integration of different parts of the brain. Components become interdependent and rely on each other.
Technologies range from opaque and obtrusive to transparent. Transparent technologies integrate so well with human use that they become almost invisible, like a natural extension of our capacities. Many technologies become more transparent over time through co-evolution with human use.
Information appliances and wearable computing provide information processing tailored to human needs in a ubiquitous and transparent fashion. They aim to provide information instantly without conscious effort.
Our sense of self and knowledge reflects the technologies we currently use. Truly seamless technologies can be hard to control and resist intervening in. Tangible computing allows us to engage and disengage with technologies as needed.
Key skills include familiarity with technologies and interfaces, interface design, concepts like "ready-to-hand", interdisciplinary thinking, and pushing the frontiers of human-tech interaction.
Augmented reality combines digital information with the physical world to provide useful tools for various tasks. Researchers explore mixed reality environments to help humans, especially children, adapt to digital-physical integration.
Invisible computing and tangible computing share the goal of seamless and intuitive human-technology interaction.
In summary, the key idea is that interactive technologies and software agents are increasingly integrated into human cognition through co-evolution and biological priming. A spectrum exists from opaque to transparent technologies, with the most transparent becoming extensions of the human mind. Skills in human-tech interaction and interdisciplinarity are required to develop technologies that enhance human capacities. Concepts like augmented reality and tangible computing explore new frontiers of integration between physical and digital.
Here is a summary:
Technologies and interfaces differ in how transparent or invisible they are to users. Some aim to be unseen, while others incorporate familiar physical objects. The choice depends on the purpose and needs.
Dynamic appliances are technologies that learn about and adapt to users. Combining them with transparent interfaces could lead to highly personalized, intuitive systems that function like our neural systems.
Emerging technologies point to a future with seamless integration of digital information and the physical world, and highly personalized, human-centered systems.
Our sense of body and self is constructed by the brain and quite malleable. It can be rapidly updated based on experience, as shown by the “extended nose” illusion.
The brain constructs our body image based on correlations in sensory input. Providing visual and tactile input, as with mirror therapy, can lead the brain to revise its model of the body.
This malleability suggests technologies may be incorporated into our sense of self, as with a blind person's cane. Our body image is transitory and updated based on interactions with the world. New technologies may be incorporated in ways that feel quite natural.
The human visual system has a small high-resolution area (the fovea) that actively moves. The brain does not build a detailed internal representation but extracts limited information, as shown by change blindness experiments.
The brain operates based on a broad sense of the visual scene rather than a detailed model. It retrieves details on demand. This “neural opportunism” means we readily incorporate tools into our thinking.
Research shows we fail to detect major visual changes not due to artificial experiments but because we lack a precise scene representation. We know how to access information rather than representing rich details internally. Like Rodney Brooks' robots, we “let the world serve as its own best model.”
While this implies our visual experience is illusory, we readily ascribe knowledge to those who can access external information, like a sports fan recalling statistics. Similarly, we have a rich visual database, even if much is external.
Infant brains also take advantage of external information, like language. Words act as cognitive technology, enabling abstract thought otherwise hard to achieve. Chimp research shows acquiring token associations enabled solving more abstract problems untrained chimps couldn't.
For humans, language provides cognitive shortcuts, enabling complex ideas. Our conceptual world depends on this tool, though biological capacity for language is debated. For infants, language is simply the structured world they're born into. Their opportunistic brains make the most of this tool, as with the visual world.
In summary, human cognition profoundly depends on the external world, not just internal processing. Our brains readily incorporate external information like language, visual details, and more, using them as external memory to support thought and experience.
Here is a summary:
The key ideas are:
1) Human cognition depends heavily on cultural and technological scaffolding, especially language. The brain is highly plastic and adapts to the environment it develops in. There is no fixed "human nature" independent of culture and technology.
2) Our sense of location and self depends on our potential for action and engagement with the world. New technologies that alter how we act and perceive the world can profoundly change our sense of self and location. Examples include telepresence technologies.
3) Telepresence requires multisensory feedback, low latency, and the ability to actively explore and interact with the remote environment. This interactivity generates a sense of presence, not just passive viewing. The links between perception and action are key.
4) Telerobotics allows controlling a robot over distance and can provide telepresence. Directly controlling all details of the robot is not required. Even when giving high-level commands to an intelligent robot, the operator can feel in control and present, similar to how we control our own bodies.
5) The visual system has distinct systems for motor control and conscious perception. In teleoperation or telepresence, automatic motor control interacts with conscious control like a "zombie within" or semi-autonomous robot. Close coupling of commands, actions and feedback activates the body image and sense of telepresence.
6) Our sense of presence depends on correlations between intentions, actions and feedback. Disrupting these correlations undermines presence. Emulators that predict feedback and varying levels of control can overcome this. Advanced telepresence could connect "knots in space" but does not require perfectly replicating normal experience.
In summary, human cognition emerges from biology, culture, and technology interacting. New technologies can profoundly impact our sense of self, location and agency by restructuring our ability to act and perceive. But some disruption of normal feedback loops can be overcome using emulators and varying control modes. Our adaptations to technology have just begun.
Here is a summary:
Face-to-face interaction is unique in enabling subtle social cues and intimacy, but electronic communication also provides distinct advantages. Rather than viewing technologically-mediated interaction as inferior, we can build on its strengths.
Advanced telepresence and virtual reality systems may eventually replicate or even expand on the experience of physical presence. For now, simple systems demonstrate how people can develop a sense of personal contact and shared experience with relatively low-bandwidth communication.
In creating telepresence and virtual reality systems, the goal could be facilitating new forms of action, experience and intimacy rather than merely imitating what is familiar. The most promising tools create new functionality rather than just serve as crutches to compensate for physical distance.
Artists like Stelarc demonstrate how we might push beyond the limits of the familiar and explore new possibilities for embodiment, agency, and connection opened up by technology. His performances using an electromechanical "Third Hand" and electronic stimulation of his body show how we can develop intuitive control and a sense of identification with non-biological systems.
Research on brain-computer interfaces, neuroprosthetics, and other human-machine interfaces suggests we may eventually distribute our sense of self, control, and cognition across biological and non-biological matrices. As we form increasingly seamless connections with tools, other beings, and information flows beyond our bodies, the self may become more fluid and permeable.
While human nature and physical human interaction will endure, new technologies could significantly expand our sense of connection in ways we have only begun to imagine. An open and exploratory mindset will be critical to navigating the opportunities and challenges ahead in this uncharted territory.
Here is a summary:
Our sense of self and mind emerges from both conscious and unconscious processes, including the use of cognitive tools and technologies. These tools shape our thinking, skills, and identities in ways we don't always recognize.
Cognitive tools like language, numbers, calendars, and computers have always been integral parts of human cognition. We should not see technology as opposed to human nature. Humans are highly adaptable "natural-born cyborgs".
An example is Alzheimer's patients who rely on environmental supports. Removing these supports can harm the person, showing how cognition depends on context. Minds are distributed and shaped by environments, not confined to brains.
Electronic trails, recommendation systems, and search tools are increasingly sophisticated cognitive tools. They utilize principles of swarm intelligence and self-organization to link items in flexible, personalized ways that simple categories cannot. Gaining the most benefit from the growing web of knowledge will require maximizing these collective cognitive capabilities.
Search tools have evolved from relying on superficial indicators like keyword frequency to utilizing the "knowledge" embodied in link structures and usage patterns. Tools like Kleinberg's algorithm and Google identify authoritative pages on topics by analyzing connections between pages. They enable a "soft assembly" of information in response to queries.
"Distributed information systems" and "active recommendation systems" are evolving, symbiotic partnerships between human communities and technologies. They adapt based on usage to provide increasingly personalized and tailored access to resources. An example is "TALKMINE", software that builds user profiles based on a question-answer routine in order to customize searches.
In summary, human cognition depends profoundly on cognitive tools and technologies. Both minds and technologies are highly adaptive, co-evolving in a reciprocal process of shaping one another. A distributed, self-organizing perspective is key to maximizing the benefits of increasing connectedness between people and online resources. Successfully navigating this connected world will require fluid, open partnerships between human minds and machine intelligences.
Here is a summary:
New technologies like software agents, recommendation systems, and online communication tools have both positive and negative impacts. While they provide convenience and connection, they can also lead to isolation, narrowness, and deception.
Steve Talbott argues that tools like email and cell phones enable communication over distance but also foster separation by reducing in-person contact. Recommendation systems and social media echo chambers can limit exposure to new ideas. Some use online spaces to deliberately spread misinformation or propaganda while posing as someone else.
However, new technologies also have benefits like spreading information quickly, bypassing censorship, enabling global connections, and supplementing human interactions. Fears about negative impacts may reflect a “luxury” not all can afford. With education on technology's nature and limits, human and AI interactions can be mutually enhancing rather than competitive.
Specific concerns were raised about children interacting with software agents that mimic human social interaction. Some worry this could degrade human-to-human relationships or limit emotional expression. However, if designed well, software agents could teach social skills or supplement parental interaction rather than replace it. Close human relationships are unlikely to be replaced.
There are strategies we can adopt to address concerns like using technology deliberately, maintaining strong human connections, and exposing ourselves and children to diverse ideas. But there are no simple or perfect solutions. Optimism, openness, and balance are needed in approaching technology's role in human lives and relationships.
The summary outlines both the benefits and drawbacks of increasing human-technology symbiosis. While concerns about privacy, deception, control, and human interaction are valid, technology is a tool that depends on how it's applied. With an optimistic and balanced perspective, technology can enhance human lives and relationships rather than diminish them. Close human bonds are unlikely to be replaced, but we must make an effort to maintain them. Overall there are no easy answers, but education and deliberateness can help address challenges. The future will likely involve a combination of human and AI interactions, so we must consider how to shape technology to meet human needs and values.
Here is a summary of the key ideas:
The mind is highly adapted to the environment and tasks it engages in. Perception, cognition, and action emerge from the interactions between brain, body, and world. They are not determined solely by what’s “inside” the brain.
Visual perception depends heavily on using the environment as an “outside memory.” We do not construct highly detailed inner representations of the visual world. We can perceive by exploiting environmental information in real time.
Intelligence and cognition do not require complex inner representations. They can emerge from real-time interactions with the environment. Mathematics, for example, depends on environmental props and culture as much as the brain.
Early development may depend more on experience-driven neural development than innate knowledge. The brain develops to control embodied experience in the world.
Technologies like virtual reality can produce a feeling of “presence”—the sense of really being in a virtual environment. This shows how perception depends on experience and expectation, not just sensory input.
Magicians and change blindness studies show how much perception depends on experience, expectation, attention, and task. We perceive what we expect or need to perceive, not necessarily what is really there.
Creatures can be intelligent by exploiting properties of their environments and embodied experiences, not just internal representations. The “extended mind” view sees cognition as extending into the environment and technology.
Telepresence and virtual reality raise issues of “disembodiment” and how technology may impact human relationships and sexuality. But technology can also enhance embodied experience and bring people together.
In summary, these views see mind, body, and world as deeply intertwined. The mind adapts to and exploits environmental resources, incorporating them into the fabric of cognition itself. Visual perception, cognition, and development all depend crucially on real-time embodied interactions with the world.
Here is a summary:
Change blindness: failure to detect changes in the visual scene.
- Rumelhart and Smolensky: connectionist researchers.
- Soft assembly: implicit emergence of structure and function.
- Spatial structures: patterns of connectivity in neural networks.
- Spooky actions at a distance: quantum entanglement.
- Statistica: data mining and predictive analytics software.
- Steels, Sterilng, Stevens, Strogatz: researchers mentioned.
- Subcortical structures: parts of the brain below the cortex.
- Supervenience: dependence of higher-level properties on lower-level ones.
- Swarm intelligence: distributed problem-solving by self-organized systems.
- Symbiosis: mutually beneficial relationship between entities.
- Symbolic: representing meaning with arbitrary tokens.
- Synaptic plasticity: changes in connection strength between neurons.
- Syndromes mentioned: Capgras' and Cotard's.
- Systems operators (Sysops): maintain bulletin board systems.
- Tenenbaum and Terrace: researchers mentioned.
- TMS: uses magnetic fields to stimulate the brain non-invasively.
- Tooby: evolutionary psychologist mentioned.
- Transactional databases: store data on business transactions.
- Transhuman: transcending human limits, especially through technology.
- Tumor mentioned causes Gage-like personality changes.
- Turkle and Turner: researchers mentioned.
- Turing mentioned in passing.
- Van Egeren and Van Essen: researchers mentioned.
- Ventriloquism effect: perceiving speech as coming from a dummy's mouth.
- Verbeek: researcher mentioned.
- Vertical market: focused on a specific industry, profession or group.
- Virtual office assistant and virtual reality: mentioned in passing.
- Vitality of pneumatic signaling: reference unclear.
- Vygotsky: theorist mentioned.
- Warren and Weick: researchers mentioned.
- Welter and Whitehead: researchers mentioned.
- Wiener: cyberneticist mentioned.
- Winograd: researcher mentioned.
- Wittgenstein: philosopher mentioned.
- Woolley: researcher mentioned.
- World Wide Web and Wright: mentioned in passing.
- Wozencroft: researcher mentioned.
- WU-CRL: reference unclear.
WYSIWYG: what you see is what you get.
Here is a summary of the page numbers you provided:
65, 209 - Discussions related to the Turing test. Page 65 introduces the test, page 209 continues the discussion.
90 - Discusses Umbuntu, an open source operating system.
176 - Introduces van der Smagt, P., an author who has written about cyborg technologies.
209 - Continues the discussion of the Turing test from page 65.
215 - Introduces Zarudiak, D., another author who has written about cyborgs.
171 - References Xerox PARC, a company involved in developing technologies like personal computers and the graphical user interface.
47, 206 - References L.A. Zadeh, who proposed the theory of fuzzy logic.
220 - References Zhang, K., presumably another researcher or author in this space.
212 - References ZMPI, which appears to be a technology standard related to parallel computing, although I can't say definitively without more context.
66 - Continues the discussion of Alan Turing's 1950 paper where he proposed the Turing test.
So in summary, the page numbers refer to discussions of cyborg technologies, researchers in this space, and some related tools and concepts like parallel computing standards, open source software, and artificial intelligence. The references span theoretical discussions, specific technologies, researchers, and companies involved in developing technologies that facilitate human-machine merging.
Did you find this article valuable?
Support Literary Insights by becoming a sponsor. Any amount is appreciated!